Bone density and fractures
The NIH fact sheet says it is not clear whether vitamin K supplements affect osteoporosis risk. It describes a 2006 meta-analysis in which fracture trials all used MK-4 at 15 or 45 mg a day (milligrams, not micrograms) and found fewer fractures; a 3-year trial of 180 mcg MK-7 a day in postmenopausal women that found better bone strength; and a 12-month trial of 381 postmenopausal women that found no difference in bone density. It calls the trial results mixed.[1]
- MK-4 dose in fracture trials
- 15 or 45 mg/day
- MK-7 dose in the 3-year trial
- 180 mcg/day
The 2006 meta-analysis in more detail
The fact sheet describes a 2006 systematic review and meta-analysis by Cockayne and colleagues. Of 13 trials, 12 found that vitamin K1 or MK-4 improved bone mineral density. Seven trials reported fractures, and in those MK-4 significantly lowered hip, vertebral and all nonvertebral fractures. These were the high milligram MK-4 doses above, not the microgram MK-7 doses in most K2 supplements.[1]
Heart disease and artery calcification
The fact sheet says clinical trial results are inconclusive. In observational studies of Dutch adults, people who ate more menaquinones had less artery calcification (564 postmenopausal women) and, in 4,807 adults aged 55 and older, a 27% to 57% lower rate of death from coronary heart disease in the higher intake groups. Phylloquinone (K1) intake showed no such link. These studies can’t show cause and effect, and few trials have tested K2 supplements for this.[1]